Hi - great job on this site. one thing that would make it better, maybe: when creating one's own power-ups, bad guys, and quests, users should be able to specify how many points they get for each thing, and more than 1 category (physical, emotional, etc.) should be available.
This would be nice. Perhaps the creation page could give you a pool of points to assign on winning, and you can split them up. E.g.:
Physical: ( )( )( )
Emotional: (o)( )( )
Social:( )( )( )
Mental:( )(o)( )
(This would mean one Emotional and two Mental.) Perhaps a randomiser to say which one of the three you get on a fail, as well.